Chapter 4: The Pun Predicament

Before discussing what makes a pun great, let's examine a short list of all the ways puns can flop.

Forced or contrived: A pun can fall flat if it feels forced or contrived, as if the writer is trying too hard to be clever. This can make it seem unnatural and disrupt the flow of conversation or writing.

Lack of subtlety: A good pun often relies on a clever play on words that requires a moment of realization from the audience. However, if the pun is too obvious or lacks subtlety, it can be perceived as juvenile or as unoriginal as a dated dad joke.

Overused or clichéd: Some puns have been used so frequently that they lose their comedic impact. Recycling tired puns can make them seem lazy or uninspired, failing to elicit genuine laughter from the audience. 

Inappropriate context: Puns rely on wordplay, which means they might not always be appropriate for every situation. Using a pun in a serious or somber context can come across as insensitive or inappropriate.

Mismatched tone: Puns often thrive in lighthearted or playful conversations but using them in contexts where a serious or formal tone is required can feel jarring and out of place. This is where you must know and target your audience.

Failure to connect: Sometimes, the connection between the words being punned is too obscure or tenuous, making it difficult for the audience to grasp the intended humor.

Overreliance: Using too many puns in quick succession can dilute their impact and make them feel tiresome rather than amusing.

Timing: Like with any joke, timing is crucial. A pun delivered at the wrong moment can miss its mark entirely and leave the audience feeling underwhelmed.

In essence, what makes a pun terrible often boils down to execution. When done well, puns can be delightful and clever. But when done poorly, they can be cringeworthy and fall flat.

Great puns and why they work

"Time flies like an arrow; fruit flies like a banana."

This pun, often attributed to Groucho Marx. Although it is difficult to pinpoint exactly when this pun was first used, it likely gained popularity during Marx's comedic performances, which occurred primarily in the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s.  What makes this pun work? It plays with the multiple meanings of the word "flies." In the first part, "time flies" is a metaphorical expression meaning that time passes quickly, while in the second part, "fruit flies" refers to the insect. The unexpected twist in the second half of the sentence, where "flies" is interpreted as a verb rather than a noun, creates a humorous contrast between the two halves of the statement.

"I'm reading a horror book in Braille. Something bad is about to happen... I can feel it."

This pun cleverly plays on the dual meaning of the word "feel." In one sense, "feel" refers to the tactile sensation experienced by someone reading Braille, while in another sense, it refers to a premonition or sense of impending danger. By using "feel" in both a literal and figurative sense, the pun creates a humorous juxtaposition between the two meanings, adding an element of surprise and wit to the statement.

"The roundest knight at King Arthur's table was Sir Cumference."

This pun relies on a clever play on words involving the name "Sir Cumference" and the mathematical concept of "circumference." By using a knight's name that sounds like "circumference," the pun creates a humorous association between the shape of a circle and the knight's name, as well as an implication the knight has a weight problem. All of these factors add an element of whimsy and cleverness to the statement.

"A bicycle can't stand on its own because it's two-tired."

This pun plays on the homophones "tired" and "tire." While "tired" typically means feeling fatigued, "tire" refers to the rubber wheel component of a bicycle. By using "tired" in place of "tire," the pun creates a clever wordplay that provides a humorous explanation for why a bicycle can't stand on its own, adding an element of surprise and wit to the statement.

Why these puns work.

Overall, these puns work because they creatively exploit the multiple meanings or interpretations of words, phrases, or names, resulting in unexpected twists that surprise and amuse the audience. They showcase the cleverness and ingenuity of wordplay, making them memorable and often cited examples of humorous language use.

Add comment


There are no comments yet.